Legislature(1999 - 2000)
03/25/1999 03:33 PM Senate STA
Audio | Topic |
---|
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
SENATE STATE AFFAIRS COMMITTEE March 25, 1999 3:33 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT Senator Jerry Ward, Chairman Senator Lyda Green Senator Gary Wilken Senator Randy Phillips Senator Kim Elton MEMBERS ABSENT None COMMITTEE CALENDAR PIONEER HOME REVIEW PREVIOUS SENATE COMMITTEE ACTION See Senate State Affairs minutes dated 3/18/99. WITNESS REGISTER Commissioner-designee Robert Poe Department of Administration PO Box 110200 Juneau, AK 99811-0200 Alison Elgee Deputy Commissioner Department of Administration PO Box 110200 Juneau, AK 99811-0200 James Kohn, Director Alaska Longevity Programs Department of Administration PO Box 110211 Juneau, AK 99811-0211 Lisa Caress-Beu 2420 Chinook Ave Anchorage, AK 99516 POSITION STATEMENT: Asked questions Marty Margeson 1401 W 13th Anchorage, AK 99501 POSITION STATEMENT: Asked questions Bud Caress 6808 Spruce Anchorage, AK 99507 POSITION STATEMENT: Asked questions Kathy Emmons PO Box 770416 Eagle River, AK 99577 POSITION STATEMENT: Asked questions ACTION NARRATIVE TAPE 99-7, SIDE A Number 001 CHAIRMAN WARD called the Senate State Affairs Committee to order at 3:33 p.m. to continue the hearing on Alaska's Pioneer Homes. Present were Senators Green, Phillips, Elton and Chairman Ward. SENATOR ELTON moved to add a letter from Mary Elizabeth Johnson to the record. There being no objection, CHAIRMAN WARD announced a copy would be distributed to all committee members. CHAIRMAN WARD informed those present that the Senate State Affairs Committee held a previous hearing about perceived problems with the Pioneer Homes. Since that hearing, he met with Commissioner- designee Poe several times. Today the Commissioner will address the concerns expressed at the previous hearing. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE ROBERT POE, Department of Administration (DOA), informed committee members he visited with families, staff and residents of the Anchorage and Palmer Pioneer Homes after the previous Senate State Affairs Committee hearing to discuss and see, first-hand, the concerns expressed about those Homes. He prefaced his discussion by saying the Pioneer Home Program is one of the unique things about Alaska; not many states provide similar programs for their long term residents, and many people have wonderful things to say about the Pioneer Homes. He pointed out many families have commented that the Pioneer Homes' staff are very dedicated to their jobs. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said most of the concerns expressed at the last meeting relate to the Anchorage Home, but some relate to the Palmer Home as well. The concerns centered around three areas; inadequate staffing levels at the Alzheimer's Disease and Related Dementia (ADRD) and Comprehensive Care Units; the distribution of medications by Certified Nursing Aides (CNAs) and poor communication with management. Families are concerned about the number of medication errors that occur and RNs believe they can better monitor residents' health by administering medications themselves. Families believe the management of the Anchorage Pioneer Home gives unsatisfactory responses to their complaints. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE stated he believes the management staff may be a bit defensive because they are very proud of the good things they do, but they need to be more open to constructive criticism. Many of the concerns expressed are related to an insufficient budget; with limited funding, only so many staff members can be hired. COMMISSIONER DESIGNEE POE identified three areas where improvements can be made, in the near future, particularly to the Anchorage Pioneer Home. Regarding the administration of medication, only RNs and LPNs will be administering medication to residents in the ADRD and Comprehensive Care Units. In addition, DOA will work with the University of Alaska to develop a longer term medication administration program for CNAs. The second improvement relates to the criticism that the Anchorage Pioneer Home changed from a skilled nursing license facility to an assisted living facility to avoid regulatory oversight. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE disagreed the change was made for regulatory reasons, and said the change was made because assisted living homes have been shown to expand the quality of life for residents with ADRD. He noted statistics show a high number of Pioneer Home residents have Alzheimer's Disease and related dementia, therefore the change to assisted living facilities was a good response to dealing with the resident population. However, as residents need more medical attention in the later stages, the assisted living model may not be have the same beneficial effect and a different model may be more appropriate. COMMISSIONER- DESIGNEE POE stated he will research what is necessary to change the Pioneer Homes to dual-license facilities: assisted living and skilled nursing facilities for the ADRD and Comprehensive Care Units. A dual model approach will come with increased costs as facility and staffing changes will be required, and a request for increased funding will have to occur. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE stated the third improvement involves communication between the Pioneer Home administration and concerned families. Last Monday he met with family members of Anchorage Pioneer Home residents to discuss creating family councils. He has committed his support to that idea, provided the group represents a broad base of families of residents. He offered to hire two consultants from Minnesota to meet with the group to provide advice on setting up the council. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE repeated his approach to resolving the three main areas of concern are to increase staffing levels, work on skilled nursing facility licensure, and create family councils to facilitate communication. ALISON ELGEE, Deputy Commissioner of DOA, and JIM KOHN, Director of Alaska Longevity Programs, joined Commissioner-designee Poe to answer questions. Number 273 SENATOR PHILLIPS commented that at a recent constituent meeting, he heard many uncomplimentary remarks about Commissioner-designee Poe's approach to the Pioneer Home complaints, and questions about which nurses can administer drugs. He noted most people concerned about the Anchorage, Palmer, and Fairbanks Pioneer Homes felt they are being patronized rather than listened to. SENATOR ELTON acknowledged the significant amount of time spent on this issue by Commissioner-designee Poe, Deputy Commissioner Elgee, and Director Kohn. He asked for DOA's position on the proposal to move some of the oversight functions of the Pioneer Homes from the Department of Administration to the Department of Health and Social Services. Number 316 DEPUTY COMMISSIONER ELGEE responded SB 20 transfers the assisted living licensing function from the Division of Senior Services in DOA to the Department of Health and Social Services, and is before this committee. DOA supports the concept, as the assisted living licensing functions are currently split; DOA licenses senior residential facilities and DHSS licenses assisted living facilities for the developmentally disabled and mental health groups. The same regulations apply to both. DOA has been working with the sponsor's staff on this proposal and agrees that a combined function in certification and licensing is a workable idea and will address some of the concerns raised. MS. ELGEE pointed out the problem with consolidation is that both departments are understaffed. Consolidation will not provide the surety that the public is looking for. Number 338 SENATOR ELTON clarified that DOA likes the idea but believes more funds will be required to accomplish the goal. MS. ELGEE said that is correct. SENATOR GREEN questioned whether a skilled nursing facility is staffed with RNs or CNAs. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE replied a skilled nursing facility license is equivalent to a nursing home license. SENATOR PHILLIPS asked if the lesser qualified staff at the Pioneer Home were given a pay increase when they were given the duty of administering medications. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said Senator Phillips was actually referring to two separate issues. CNAs dispense medications under the supervision and license of an RN. After discussing that issue with families and staff, he agrees that only RNs and LPNs should dispense medications in the Comprehensive Care and ADRD Units, and that an intensive training program should be offered to CNAs. Number 373 CHAIRMAN WARD interjected to ask what the Pioneer Homes' policy is to reduce the number of medical error reports, and whether a security problem exists regarding medications in the facilities. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE acknowledged that medication errors did occur, and repeated his belief that allowing only RNs and LPNs to administer medications will minimize the problem. Regarding Senator Phillips' question about the pay raises, DIRECTOR JIM KOHN stated each Pioneer Home has an assisted living coordinator. The Anchorage Pioneer Home recently filled three assisted living coordinator positions. During the hiring process, the Home decided the team leaders would best fit the positions so three long-time staff members were reclassified and promoted. Those employees were LPNs. Although their pay range changed from 13 to 17, the amount of their raises was minimal because their longevity had placed them at a step almost equivalent to a range 17. Number 438 SENATOR GREEN asked whether reluctance on the part of RNs to put their licenses on the line and allow CNAs to administer medications will have any effect on whether they are hired or retained. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE replied the employee should follow the rules set by the Board of Nursing. SENATOR GREEN questioned whether the Board of Nursing has taken any action or a new position on CNA administration of medications. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said it has not, and that he just began to address the issue last week. CHAIRMAN WARD asked what assurance of safety and quality care a level 4 or 5 resident can expect. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE replied he spoke with the daughter of the resident who broke her hip after being pushed by another resident. The daughter, an RN in geriatric care, was remarkably understanding about the situation. The daughter pointed out inadequate staffing lead to the problem. He stated the 60 new staff positions requested in the FY00 budget will increase the number of staff in the more critical wards. In addition, he and Deputy Commissioner Elgee have been looking at ways to concentrate more staff members in those critical areas. Number 476 CHAIRMAN WARD referred to a memo written by a Pioneer Home supervisor to the nursing staff directing that time spent on medical error reports be minimized. He asked about that policy and questioned what happens to prescribed narcotics that are not administered. MR. KOHN replied the Pioneer Home policy is to write down any unusual occurrence regarding medications, whether harm was caused or not, and include whether medications are given at the correct time. He explained if a medication is to be given at 8:00, it can be administered between 7:00 and 9:00; that is hospital procedure. If a medication is not given within that time period, a report is written. Often, the medication is given ten minutes after the allotted time span. He noted the memo was written to inform staff that if medications can be administered within the allotted time span, that should be done, and medical error reports need not be written. He emphasized the Pioneer Homes' policy and practice is to report any irregular activity regarding medications. CHAIRMAN WARD again asked Mr. Kohn to speak to the issue of the security of drugs and what happens to drugs that are not administered properly. MR. KOHN noted that the incident Chairman Ward referred to, in which a medication was left on a nightstand, involved an RN, and was unacceptable. MR. KOHN stated, regarding the security of medications, the in-house pharmacy allows restocking of some unused medications if they remain in their original packaging and are untouched. In the past when the Pioneers Homes contracted with independent pharmacies, all unused medications had to be destroyed. CHAIRMAN WARD asked if an accounting of unused medications exists. MR. KOHN said such a report is kept, and he would provide a copy to the Chairman. He added the in-house pharmacy has recently raised the level of safety of unused medications. MR. KOHN also offered to provide committee members with a forthcoming report from Dr. Brad Williams, Chairman of the pharmaceutical department at the University of Southern California, who recently spent a week assessing the Pioneer Home pharmacies. CHAIRMAN WARD asked if patients are charged for prescription medications they do not receive. MR. KOHN answered in the past, medications provided by independent pharmacies could not be returned, even if unused. Most unused medications can now be returned to the in-house pharmacy. Inexpensive medications are not returned because it is not worth the handling charge, but narcotics do not fall in that category. CHAIRMAN WARD asked if patients were charged for medications they did not receive and were disposed. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE stated they were charged for medications that were not worth the cost of restocking. CHAIRMAN WARD verified that COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE could supply an accounting to the committee of when unused medications were disposed of, and by whom. MR. KOHN clarified the Pioneer Home tracks all prescribed medications that are disposed of and a log is kept of medications that are returned to the pharmacy. SENATOR GREEN asked if the pharmacy at the Anchorage Pioneer Home supplies drugs to the Anchorage and Palmer Homes. MR. KOHN explained that pharmacy supplies medications to five of the six homes; all but the home in Juneau. TAPE 99-7, SIDE B SENATOR GREEN asked why the Juneau Home is not included. MR. KOHN replied it will be after the first of July. SENATOR GREEN asked if using the Anchorage in-house pharmacy has resulted in a cost savings. MR. KOHN replied the normal cost savings to residents ranges from 25 to 75 percent. The in-house pharmacy has a contract that allows it to buy large quantities of medications at a very low cost. About one-half of the residents receive state assistance because they are no longer able to pay the rate. At that point, the state pays for the medications. Keeping the cost of medications down also enables patients to stretch their money farther and stay off state assistance longer. SENATOR GREEN asked if the pharmacy is licensed. MR. KOHN said it is. SENATOR WILKEN asked about the structure of the pharmacies. MR. KOHN explained prior to the creation of the centralized pharmacy, the Pioneer Homes had six individual contracts with pharmacies; one for each home. Several problems existed with that system: some homes had difficulty finding a willing pharmacy to contract with; uniform packaging of medications for ease of administration was difficult; and the homes needed pharmacy consultations geared to a geriatric population. SENATOR WILKEN questioned whether the pharmacy manager at the Anchorage Pioneer Home is responsible for reviewing the records of residents at the individual homes, and whether the manager is a state employee. MR. KOHN replied two pharmacists are employed at the Anchorage Pioneer Home pharmacy and both are state employees. They access all residents' records through a statewide computer system. All medication orders are checked against the patients chart for possible drug interactions and polypharmacy. Number 541 COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE pointed out the centralized records are useful for several reasons. Contraindications are built into the pharmacy system and several people track medical prescriptions for residents. SENATOR ELTON asked for a definition of "medications." MR. KOHN stated he was referring to FDA-approved medications and a few over- the-counter drugs taken for therapeutic reasons. SENATOR ELTON asked what practice is used to destroy drugs in nursing facilities and who is charged for the drugs. MR. KOHN replied Medicaid provides a standardized amount of money for each patient in a Medicaid facility, and those facilities struggle with that method. SENATOR GREEN noted the opening of the Anchorage Pioneer Home pharmacy was not without incident and conversations about its problems continue. MR. KOHN agreed the opening of the pharmacy was a big undertaking. However, he noted, no one suffered from not receiving medications. He repeated the forthcoming report from Dr. Brad Williams should be helpful to all involved. Number 482 CHAIRMAN WARD announced testimony would be taken from teleconference participants. He informed those participants their questions will be responded to in writing by Department of Administration staff. KAREN ROBERTS, former Assisted Living Care Coordinator at the Palmer Pioneer Home, stated COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE's statements have been directed to problems at the Anchorage Pioneer Home. She asked if the problems at the other five homes will be addressed. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE replied most of the concerns expressed to date have been about the Anchorage Pioneer Home so his immediate focus has been on that home. SENATOR GREEN recommended that the new policy on the administration of medications be applied to the Palmer Pioneer Home immediately. MS. ROBERTS emphasized her belief that assisted living is a great concept, but regulations need to be put in place. She also asked that management review the job classifications of range 17 LPNs. She believes they are under worked and overpaid. Number 440 COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE informed Ms. Roberts he looked at that issue and explained the State pay scale system with ranges and steps. He noted that those LPNs received a minor pay increase overall. He added the three coordinator positions are mid-level management positions in a home with 226 residents. LISA CARESS-BEU stated she has never received a credit for medications that were prescribed but not given to her mother at the Anchorage Pioneer Home. She asked whether she is being double- billed. MR. KOHN answered that any medications not given on schedule would eventually be given. However, if medications were returned to the pharmacy, she should get a credit, unless the medication is too inexpensive to warrant the time taken to give the credit. He offered to review her mother's medication record. CHAIRMAN WARD thought all records should be checked against the disposal documentation. MS. CARESS-BEU stated, regarding medication security, she has dated photographs of a medication cabinet left open wide and also with the key in the lock. The most recent photograph is less than ten days old. She expressed concern that the medication security policy is not followed. MR. KOHN suggested Ms. Caress-Beu tell someone right away. Number 375 CHAIRMAN WARD noted the State Affairs Committee's top priority is the safety and health of Pioneer Home residents and that the committee is not interested in placing blame, but on getting resolution to the problems discussed. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said he also saw an unlocked medicine cabinet while he was at the Anchorage home, and although he did not believe the situation was dangerous, the cabinets should be locked at all times. He repeated his plan to only allow RNs and LPNs to administer medications, and to provide a CNA training program in alignment with the Board of Nursing policies. Number 239 SENATOR PHILLIPS stated that it was not the previous witness' responsibility to do something about an unlocked medicine cabinet, it is the responsibility of the Department of Administration. He added he heard more emotional complaints from constituents on this issue than on any other, and it is DOA's responsibility to do something to solve the problem. MR. KOHN apologized for giving the impression that he thought it was the witness' responsibility. He clarified he meant to empower her to report such a situation immediately so that it can be corrected right away. SENATOR PHILLIPS repeated DOA needs to investigate those complaints. MR. KOHN stated the policy is to keep medication cabinets locked at all times. CHAIRMAN WARD asked COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE to respond to a fax from Marty Margeson regarding health and safety concerns at the Anchorage Pioneer Home. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE stated he met with Ms. Margeson and viewed photographs of her father. He repeated that more staff has been requested in the FY00 budget, and the increased staff will focus on the problem areas. He added the resident who assaulted Ms. Margeson's father has been moved to the Alaska Psychiatric Institute (API). He noted Ms. Caress-Beu suggested placing video cameras in residents' rooms so that residents can be observed by nurses at the nurses station. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE stated he can only try to make sure that resources will be allocated to protect the residents, and that is what he will do. Number 239 MARTY MARGESON stated a current resident caused injury to her father on three occasions and has harmed other residents. The Anchorage Pioneer Home has responded by putting this resident on a one-to-one staff watch, and physically and chemically restraining the resident. However, the harm continues because the techniques are applied inconsistently. She asked what DOA's plans are for this resident, and whether DOA will order the Pioneer Homes to provide a safe environment for all residents. If violations occur, those violations should be reported to the Ombudsman and licensing board. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said he has no problem with a policy that says that DOA wants to guarantee the health and safety of the residents, but he needs time to think about how that will be done. In the case of the resident who continues to cause harm, COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said he will discuss the situation with Mr. Kohn to determine the best course of action. He reminded everyone that Alzheimer's patients sometimes become physically aggressive, and that he cannot make a snap decision about what that patient needs. CHAIRMAN WARD asked Ms. Margeson if she was satisfied with COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE's reply that he would review the situation and come to a decision expeditiously. MS. MARGESON said she would like to know how families should respond when licensees violate policy and refuse to implement systems to protect residents. MR. KOHN replied that the Pioneer Home reports violations to Adult Protective Services (APS). DOA does its own investigation and APS has the option of doing a separate investigation. MS. MARGESON asked Mr. Kohn if APS would have six reports of violations against her father. MR. KOHN stated he could not tell her what APS would have. CHAIRMAN WARD interjected that if no reports exist, then the procedure does not work and a new procedure must be part of the overall change. Number 160 KATHY EMMONS from Eagle River asked why LPNs were hired to fill the Assisted Living Coordinator positions at range 17, when RNs are paid at a range 15 and supervise LPNs. MR. KOHN replied the Assisted Living Coordinator position does not require a nursing background, although it is helpful. He explained Assisted Living Coordinators do not supervise the professional nursing staff, they schedule activities and coordinate staff. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE pointed out that RNs receive about $1827 per pay period and the Assisted Living Coordinators receive about $1699. MS. EMMONS said she has a problem with the fact that the Assisted Living Coordinators who are LPNs are telling RNs when to make out medication error reports. CHAIRMAN WARD informed Ms. Emmons that COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE would provide a response to her question in writing. BUD CARESS from Anchorage stated he met with COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE last week and was very impressed with him. He asked COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE what the odds are that the FY 00 budget requests for the Pioneers Homes will be granted. CHAIRMAN WARD interjected to ask COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE to address Mr. Caress' question and to sum up his proposed changes, as those will have an effect on putting additional funds in the FY 00 budget for the Pioneer Homes. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said he was optimistic that additional funds will be added to the Pioneer Homes budget, even though it is late in the budget process. He clarified that the additional funds are not in the supplemental budget, they are in the FY 00 budget request. The FY 00 budget contains funds for 60 additional positions, and that money would be available in July, 1999. He and Mr. Kohn plan to use those 60 positions to deal with the immediate concerns in the ADRD and Comprehensive Care Units. He pointed out it will take time to research the dual model approach, including the licensing requirements and other necessary changes. He hopes to talk to family council members this summer about alternatives to solve the problems that are occurring. He repeated he is optimistic about the FY00 budget increase because he believes legislators understand changes cannot be made without funding. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE concluded the Pioneer Homes would be improved by three changes: medication administration by RNs and LPNs only; dual licensing to include a skilled nursing facility license; and enhanced training for CNAs that is aligned with Board of Nursing policies. TAPE 99-8, Side B Number 000 SENATOR WILKEN pointed out this Legislature funded a $500,000 request in the supplemental budget for staff for the Pioneer Homes and legislation has been introduced that will designate Pioneer Home receipts which will amount to $2.6 million in FY00. CHAIRMAN WARD informed COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE that many people are concerned about retaliation against their family members residing at the Pioneer Homes. SENATOR GREEN read a fax sent to the committee that said APS and the Long-term Care Ombudsman have no reports of harm from the Anchorage Pioneer Home. The sender asked what Commissioner- designee Poe plans to do to ensure that reports of harm get reported to the Office of the Long-term Care Ombudsman (OLTCO). MR. KOHN said he would be agreeable to having the OLTCO be involved in reports of harm. The current statute requires reports of harm be made to APS. CHAIRMAN WARD asked for a more detailed written response to determine what the Commissioner's intentions are. He also asked the Commissioner to explain his policy on retaliation. COMMISSIONER-DESIGNEE POE said he talked with many employees and others when in Anchorage, and he told them then, and repeats now, that no retaliation will occur for honest discussion of the problems. He also gave some of them his business card so that they can call him directly if retaliation does occur. He emphasized the important thing to recognize is that frequently those who complain are viewed as detracting from the positive things that are occurring. He noted the criticisms do not make the statement that the Pioneers Home is not doing good things. CHAIRMAN WARD informed Commissioner-designee Poe that the questions that were faxed to the committee would be forwarded to his office for responses. He then adjourned the meeting at 5:10 p.m.
Document Name | Date/Time | Subjects |
---|